Slate Article: Kill Shelter Pets and Feed Them to Your Own Dogs and Cats Because WhaddayaGonnaDo?
Most pet owners don’t like to think about killing pets in shelters. Even fewer like to think about the possibility of those dead shelter pets being ground up for use as an ingredient in pet food. While I don’t know of any unequivocal proof that dead shelter pets sent to rendering facilities end up being purchased as a protein source by pet food manufacturers, I think it’s a question worth asking.
Slate asked the question last week and tragicallybungled the thing worse than I could have imagined. The author determines that dead shelter pets are likely in your pet’s food dish but closes with this so very wrong paragraph:
Go ahead, feed this stuff to your dogs. I’m not kidding. They have to eat something, and this is what is available. Until we have a better answer for the millions of unwanted pets waiting in shelters for homes that aren’t there, and until we figure out a more efficient means of turning subsidized grain into steak, this stuff exists, and we’ve got to do something with it. Put Lassie on the label, since she’s on the menu anyway. If you don’t like it, adopt a shelter dog and make sure it’s neutered.
Fail, fail everywhere and all the brains did shrink.
Dogs do have to eat something but commercial mystery meat food is not the only thing available. Table scraps, in their various forms, have been used to feed dogs since dogs started hanging around humans and there were no “subsidized grains” being turned into steak then. There are plenty of other foods dogs can be fed besides steak anyway.
Millions of shelter pets are not unwanted. They are wanted. Shelters and rescues prevent pets from getting into homes by keeping the pets hidden, turning down adopters who don’t meet arbitrary criteria such as a fenced yard and failing to do their jobs overall.
Homes are there. More than enough homes. Check the math.
I have adopted shelter dogs. I’ve gotten them neutered. It didn’t make any shelter directors do their jobs. Problem still unsolved. Or to put it more lovingly, your solution sucks, makes no sense and sucks more.
Share this:
Like this:
Leave a Reply
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Name*
Email*
Website
Comment
Notify me of follow-up comments via email.
Notify me of new posts via email.
- marylanddogfederation on April 23, 2013 at 8:49 am
- At least you got it right the second time. If at first you don’t succeed try, try again.
- Reply
- toddie11 on April 23, 2013 at 10:44 am
- X
- Reply
- Salette Ann Andrews on April 23, 2013 at 10:51 am
- My dogs eat what we eat. I would never feed them cows or pigs, much less other dogs and cats.
- Reply
- toddie11 on April 23, 2013 at 10:54 am
- I have the fact sheet signed by Los Angeles Animal Control that breaks down where the rendererd yes renered pet go and the products shelter animals are made into.. Tallow is the fat rendered pets.. from the shelters own facts sheet as if it’s nothing..soap, cosmetics, shampoo, crayons, tires.. fish meal to feed the fish farm raised in China..One company serves all the very low cost contact in S. Cal.. Because the ingredients are then resold!!!! I can send you the FYI sheet from the director Marcia Mayeda.. While they won’t admit pet food.. The meal goes to China..the FYI sheet was shocking they acted like this was ok with society.. As long as they have NO knowledge the company sells for pet food..!!!!!
My lipstick, tires, children’s crayons!! Soap! - Unknown to me products I buy!
- Reply
- Karen F on April 23, 2013 at 3:17 pm
- Not too often you see someone take a subject like food and turn it into an apology for shelter killing, but then again, this is a man who argues for hunting, killing and eating animals that have been introduced to the continent (“invasive species” from which we are “under attack”). So he’s someone predisposed to think that there are animals who should be classified as “extra.”
- A much higher quality of research — and different conclusions — can be found in Ted Kerasote’s new book Pukka’s Promise. Kerasote visited rendering plants in person and spoke with rendering company executives as part of his preparation for writing. In the part of the book that’s about food (for both pets and people), he included detailed descriptions of what he saw and learned.
- Reply
- YesBiscuit on April 24, 2013 at 8:04 am
- Thanks for the heads up. I actually have that book but went straight for the chapter on tubal ligations/vasectomies. I need to go back and have a look at the rest of the book.
- Reply
- Isabel Vanover on April 23, 2013 at 3:24 pm
- WHAT A STUPID JERK!
- Reply
- Victoria Brooks on April 23, 2013 at 10:09 pm
- I have seen “animal” and “meat” listed as ingredients on pet food. While I don’t know if it is dead dogs and cats, the fact that it is not listed as a type of animal raises red flags to me. I don’t want Rocky eating dead Fluffy. Frankly, my dogs love human food. Prior to having some strongly worded conversations with some of my vets, when I was just started having pets, they pretty much ate most of what I ate (I knew what was on the forbidden list). They were much happier that way. My mother told me it is natural for them to eat leftovers, she said – what do you think they did before there was dog food?
- Reply
- rachel on April 24, 2013 at 1:48 am
- Never mind the fact that having your dog or cat eat another dog or cat is just wrong, those shelter pets have been (or should have been) killed with extremely strong, extremely dangerous drugs. If your animal eats other animals killed with those drugs, your pet ingests those drugs.
I read a book a few years ago, and it was several years old even then, about the dangers of commercial pet food. I wish I could remember the name of either the author or the book. The author had found the same information abot dead pets going to rendering plants that then sold the rendered products to pet food makers. Pets that ate this food seemed extra sensitive to aenesthesia drugs, having reactions they shouldn’t, had they only had the drugs at times known to the vet. Some of these reactions were strong enough to kill.
(Please note, it has been several years since I read this book so this information is very vague and may be slightly inaccurate.) - Reply
- toddie11 on April 24, 2013 at 9:45 am
- I think proof of our the other consumers products I have the lost directly from LA Animal Care and Control is enough said about rendering shelter pets.
I would be happy to e-mail you the list yesbiscuit and it directly from the directer. All the shelter contact the same company because no others accepts dogs or cats.
The Q and A is very shocking and that they write it likes it nothing is just horrible.
Just comment someone if the want it.
It’s you SOAP..Cosmetics.. And, more!!! - Reply
- YesBiscuit on April 24, 2013 at 9:46 am
- My e-mail iseiderdown@yesbiscuit.comif you would like to send me a copy. Thank you.
- toddie11 on April 24, 2013 at 1:34 pm
- I will pull you the information as soon S I
get to
my desktop YesBiscuit.. It will make a interesting blog.. People don’t believe until
they read.. They think it rumor and myth I found the in shelter documents.. ! - ezbuddy on April 24, 2013 at 6:21 pm
- I have read that rendering plants do sell ingredients to dog & cat food manufacturing plants that does go into the dog/cat food Spot & Fluffy eats. Their ingredients also go into chicken, cow & pig feed. Look at the by-product ingredients on your pet food bags. I have also read about the shameful dog pound & rendering plant in southern California.
- Twenty five years ago, Memphis used to have a rendering plant & the smell reeked throughout the entire area. Dog food was also made within that area which was blamed for the smells. It did smell sort of like dog food. And there was a rumor long ago of MAS sending their kills to that rendering plant. I can’t verify it, but I’ve heard about it many times.
- Reply
- toddie11 on April 24, 2013 at 6:32 pm
- Yesbiscuit I sent the rendering doc’s to your e-mail for LA/CA.
- Reply
- ezbuddy on April 24, 2013 at 7:05 pm
- Can you send me a copy?
- Juile Jo on April 26, 2013 at 12:13 pm
- That is why I buy the $50.00 bag instead of the $5.00 bag. I also read everything that is listed on the bag to make sure that MY dogs and cats don’t end up with all of the residual garbage that I know is going into the other foods. I knew about the rendering of dead pound animals over 20 years ago. I was told this by the manager of a shelter here in California. And the drugs that are used to “safely put them to sleep”, do get transferred into the food that has it in it. It can make pets sick. So check the ingredients people. Your pet depends on it.
- Reply
Where was that thing on this blog?
Adoptable at UPAWS in MI
That Other Blog
Pages
- About Me
- Comment Policy, Corrections, Tips
- Kick In for Blog Expenses
- MAS Security Camera Footage
- Memphis Animal Services – Take Action
- Nominate a Shelter Pet of the Day
- Photos Posted by ACO in CA
- The Truth about HSUS
- The Truth about PETA
Recent Comments
Daniela on Tools in the Toolbox Discussio…
YesBiscuit on Tools in the Toolbox Discussio…
Daniela on Tools in the Toolbox Discussio…
YesBiscuit on Tools in the Toolbox Discussio…
bestuvall on Tools in the Toolbox Discussio…
Daniela on Tools in the Toolbox Discussio…
Dot Kirby on Case Update: Ohio SPCA Taking…
Vick on Yet Another Pet Suffers in a C…
Natalie on Case Update: Ohio SPCA Taking…
DoggyMomma on Animal Abuser on Trial is the…
Elayna Cannata on North Ridgeville, OH: A Layer…
Evdon Stogner on Case Update: Ohio SPCA Taking…
Elayna Cannata on Case Update: Ohio SPCA Taking…
Dot Kirby on Case Update: Ohio SPCA Taking…
maggiecrooks on Case Update: Ohio SPCA Taking…
Email Subscription
Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
Join 676 other followers
Classic YesBiscuit!
- Are You Enabling the Needless Killing of Shelter Pets?
- Defining No Kill Sheltering
- Dumping "Dump"
- FOIA Requests: Samples and Links
- Road Map to Reform
- The Biggest Animal Welfare Myth in the South
- The Killings Will Continue Until Morale Improves
- What Choice Does Your Shelter Director Make?
Find a Friend
- American Lab Rescue
- Animal Protection League
- Atlanta Beagle Rescue
- Beagle Rescue Links
- Big on Beagles
- Dogs in Danger
- Lowcountry House Rabbit Society
- Nose to the Ground to Help Hounds
- Petfinder
- Safe Hounds Beagle Rescue
- Your Local No Kill Shelter
No Kill
- Alley Cat Allies
- Animal Ark
- Animal Wise Radio
- Austin No Kill Coalition
- Fix Austin
- Fix Austin Blog
- Fix NC
- Fix San Francisco
- For the Love of Dog Rescue
- Justice for Bella
- KC Dog Blog
- Maddie's Fund
- National Canine Research Council
- New Mexico Pets Alive
- No Kill Advocacy Center
- No Kill Allegany
- No Kill Blog
- No Kill Communities
- No Kill Declaration
- No Kill Houston
- No Kill Kershaw Co
- No Kill Memphis
- No Kill Nation
- No Kill Nation Blog
- No Kill Tallahassee
- O is for Onward
- Oreo's Law
- Pets Alive
- Roanoke No Kill Coalition
- Save Shelter Pets
- Saving Pets
- Strayed (video)
- Vox Felina
- Welcome Home Sanctuary
- Wisconsin Watchdog
Pet Care Basics
- A little book to bring comfort
- ASPCA Low Cost Spay-Neuter Database
- NeuterSpay.org
- Your Dog's Nutritional Needs (pdf)
Resources for No Kill Advocates
- Debunking Pet Overpopulation
- No Kill Equation
- Shelter Stats – CA
- Shelter Stats – MI
- Shelter Stats – NC
- Shelter Stats – OH (Canine)
- Shelter Stats – VA
- The No Kill Revolution Starts with YOU
RIF
- Blue Dog State
- Brindle Stick
- Carpe K-9
- Caveat
- Cruel Crazy Beautiful World
- Disapproving Rabbits
- Dog Foster Mom
- Dogged
- For the Pit Bulls
- For Your Entertainment
- Forest Walks
- Frogdog
- Full Cry: A Hound Blog
- Honest Dog
- Humane Watch
- John Sibley
- Lassie, Get Help
- Lolcats
- Loldogs
- No Pitbull Bans
- One Pibble's Wish
- Our Pack
- Petsit USA
- Raised by Wolves
- Rural Shelter Help
- Smartdogs
- Social Mange
- The Poodle and Dog Blog
- They are What They Eat
- U.S. Service Dog Registry
- Underdogged
Recent Posts
- Tools in the Toolbox Discussion: Australia’s “Getting to Zero” Campaign
- Case Update: Ohio SPCA Taking Action on Behalf of Slain Kittens
- Yet Another Pet Suffers in a Cage at the $7 Million Memphis “Shelter”
- Open Thread
- Name That Animal
- Gosh, when do they have time to eat 5 billion birds?
- “They’re doing the best they can!” – Lowndes Co Edition
- North Ridgeville, OH: A Layer Cake of Absurdity
- Just One Day – Share How Your Shelter is Participating
- The Blog’s Facebook Page Will be Inactivated
- Treats on the Internets
- Healdsburg Shelter Threatens to Kill Animals Over Money
- Mental Health Break – Music
- News Out of Broward Co is Not Good
- Another Former MAS Employee Convicted of Animal Cruelty
Click Daily to Feed Shelter Dogs
Are you opposed to killing friendly pets in shelters?
Yes - all healthy/treatable pets should be cared for until adopted
No - killing shelter pets is appropriate
ACO misconduct adoption screening Alabama 44 animal advocacy animal control killing pets animal cruelty animal rights legislation animal shelteranimal shelter abuse animal shelter improvements aspca available rescue pets behavior Best Friends Animal Societyblog breeding breed profiling breed specific legislation cats Charlotte-Mecklenburg ACCChesterfield Co shelter dog bitesdogfighting enablers FDA feral cats food safety foster gas chamber general pet caregood samaritan holidays home prepared pet diets HSUS human-animal bond kittenlame totally lame legislation life the universe and everything lost pets mandatory spay neutermarketing shelter pets memorialmemphis animal shelter Michael Vick my petsname that animal natural disasterneedless animal shelter killing No Kill oddball oh really oops-killing open thread PETA pet food pet food recall pet food safety police killing dogs puppy millsrecipe rescue responsible animal carerobeson co animal shelter safety around dogsScout Shelter Pet of the Day south carolina pet news south carolina sheltersouthern shelters strays stupid is as stupid does treats on internets wild animals wildside kennels
Archives
- June 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- August 2012
- July 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- March 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
The views expressed in this blog are the opinion of the author.
"That which haunts us will always find a way out. The wound will not heal unless given witness. The shadow that follows us is the way in." - Rumi